The method
SMART Goals vs Affirmation Goals: Examples and When to Use Each
A SMART goal is a test your goal has to pass. An affirmation goal is a sentence you write every day. They aren't rivals, and the best goals use both.
The method
You've probably heard that people who write their goals down achieve more. Here's what the research actually found, why writing may help, and what changes when you write from memory.
Almost every self-help book says the same thing: write your goals down. The advice is so common that it’s hard to tell whether it’s wisdom or habit. So what does the psychology of writing goals down actually say?
The short answer is that the evidence is real but modest, and it’s not the evidence most people quote. This post separates the myth from the research, explains why writing may help, and looks at one detail that’s easy to miss: whether you write from memory or copy yesterday’s list.
You may have seen this story. A class of Harvard or Yale graduates was asked whether they had written goals. Only 3% had. Twenty years later, that 3% supposedly earned ten times as much as everyone else combined.
It never happened. No one has been able to trace the study to a real source. The psychologist Gail Matthews went looking for it and concluded, in her own research summary, that it is an urban myth. If you’ve quoted it, you’re in good company, but it’s time to retire it.
The myth did one useful thing: it prompted real research on whether writing goals matters.
Gail Matthews of Dominican University ran an experiment on this question. Here is what her research summary reports:
The results, in plain terms:
That’s a useful finding, and it’s worth being exact about its limits. Progress was self-rated, the follow-up was four weeks, and many participants dropped out. We also found the study only as the author’s research summary, not as a peer-reviewed paper. So it supports the idea that writing helps, without proving how much.
Notice, too, that writing alone wasn’t the best condition. The highest results came when writing was joined by accountability: sharing commitments and reporting progress. We’ll come back to that.
Matthews’ study doesn’t tell us why writing helped, so we have to look at related research. Three ideas fit the evidence well.
It’s hard to write “get healthier” without noticing how empty it is. Writing forces you to choose words, and choosing words forces you to be concrete.
That matters because specificity is one of the best-supported ideas in goal research. In a review of about 35 years of studies, psychologists Edwin Locke and Gary Latham describe how goals that are specific and challenging lead to better performance than vague goals such as “do your best.” A written goal is easier to make specific, because you can see where it’s fuzzy.
Memory researchers have a name for the benefit of producing something rather than just reading it: the generation effect. A meta-analysis of 86 studies by Bertsch and colleagues found that people remember information they generate better than information they only read, with an average benefit of almost half a standard deviation.
Those studies used things like word pairs, not life goals, so this is an analogy rather than direct proof. But the logic carries over. A goal you’ve put into your own words is one you’ve thought through, and it’s easier to remember than one you copied from a template.
You can’t track what you haven’t recorded. A 2016 meta-analysis by Harkin and colleagues pooled 138 experiments (almost 20,000 people) and found that interventions that got people to monitor their progress improved goal attainment. The effect was larger when the progress was physically recorded or made public.
Most of those studies were about health behaviors, such as diet or smoking, so don’t read too much into them for every kind of goal. Still, the pattern is consistent with Matthews’ result: a written record plus some accountability beats a private intention.
Here’s the part where most advice stops. It tells you to write goals down, but not how. There’s a real difference between rewriting your goals from memory and copying last week’s list.
Retrieving something from memory strengthens it more than looking at it again. Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke tested this in 2006. Students read prose passages, then either re-read them or took recall tests. Five minutes later, re-reading looked better. After two days and a week, the students who had been tested remembered substantially more, even though re-reading made them feel more confident.
That last detail is worth sitting with. Copying a list feels productive and familiar. But familiarity isn’t the same as knowing.
Nobody has run a study comparing “goals written from memory” with “goals copied from yesterday.” We’d be making that up if we claimed otherwise. But the memory research suggests a reasonable bet:
This is the idea behind Brian Tracy’s daily practice, which we explain in our guide to the 10 goals method: ten goals, rewritten every day, without looking at the old ones. It’s also why Tenly hides your past goal entries for 30 days. The 30-day lockout isn’t a restriction for its own sake. It removes the temptation to copy, so your list stays something you recall rather than something you transcribe.
If writing alone isn’t the whole story, what completes it? Matthews’ best-performing groups point the way: a plan for action and some accountability. Here’s a simple routine built on that.
The whole thing takes about five minutes, and you can see the full routine in how to write 10 goals every day.
Try it in Tenly: Each morning, write your goals from memory, choose your Magic Wand goal and note one step. In the evening, your Evening Review lets you look back over the day’s goals. Because older entries stay hidden, you’ll be recalling your goals, not copying them.
It’s worth being clear-eyed, because the hype around goal setting can do harm.
What you can say honestly is that writing your goals is a cheap, quick habit with a plausible mechanism and some supporting evidence. That’s a good reason to try it for a month and see what you notice.
There's some evidence that it helps. In one study, people who wrote their goals reported more progress after four weeks than people who only thought about them. The study was small and relied on self-reports, so it's a good sign, not a guarantee.
No. The story that 3% of graduates had written goals and later earned ten times more has never been traced to a real study. Psychologist Gail Matthews, who ran an actual experiment on written goals, has said it is an urban myth.
The research on goals doesn't settle this. What seems to matter is that you produce the words yourself and keep a record. Choose whichever you'll do every day. A notebook by the bed and a phone app both work.
Memory research shows that generating information yourself and recalling it from memory tends to stick better than re-reading it. Writing from memory also shows you which goals are still alive for you and which have quietly faded.
Enough to cover what matters, but few enough to recall without looking. Ten is a common number because it fits in your head, and you can start with fewer and let the list grow.